The 7 summits
My atlas shows a 5,030 m mountain in Papua that is higher than Carstensz Pyramid. Is it?
No. The 5,030 m16,503 ft figure on many atlases belongs to Ngga Pulu, a snow summit next to Carstensz Pyramid, and it was measured during the first expeditions of the 1930s when Ngga Pulu carried a thick ice cap. The ice has since melted, and modern surveys put Ngga Pulu at about 4,862 m15,951 ft and Carstensz Pyramid, whose summit is bare rock, at 4,884 m16,024 ft. Carstensz Pyramid is the highest point of Oceania; the higher figure is a relic that maps copy from one another, and some of them attach it to the wrong peak.
What happened
The 1936 Colijn expedition measured Ngga Pulu at about 5,030 m16,503 ft, an ice summit rising from the Carstensz glaciers, and for decades it was listed as the highest peak in New Guinea.
Later expeditions and satellite surveys found Carstensz Pyramid's rock summit at 4,884 m16,024 ft and the ice on Ngga Pulu shrinking every year.
By the 1970s Ngga Pulu had lost enough ice to fall below Carstensz Pyramid, and the glaciers have gone on retreating; the last of them are expected to disappear within a few years.
Why the map is wrong
Cartographers copy heights from earlier maps, and a figure from 1936 has survived several generations of atlases. It is a good illustration of why the site's summit heights come from recent surveys rather than from reference books. The guide chapter Climbing Ngga Pulu describes the snow peak, and The mountain and the Sudirman Range the geography and the glaciers.
