The 7 summits
What are the official 7 summits, and what about Kosciuszko?
There is no official body, so there are two accepted lists. Everest, Aconcagua, Denali, Kilimanjaro, Elbrus and Vinson are on both; the Kosciuszko list (Dick Bass’s) adds Kosciuszko and the Carstensz Pyramid list (Reinhold Messner’s) adds Carstensz Pyramid.
The 7 summits have two versions because the highest point of Australia and Oceania depends on where the continent ends. Dick Bass, who invented the challenge and completed it in 1985, used Kosciuszko, 2,228 m7,310 ft, the highest point of the Australian mainland. Reinhold Messner argued that the continent includes New Guinea, which sits on the same continental shelf, and that its highest point, Carstensz Pyramid at 4,884 m16,024 ft, is the true seventh summit; Pat Morrow completed that version first in 1986. There is no authority to settle it. This site keeps both lists, and most serious finishers climb both.
The case for Kosciuszko
Encyclopaedias define a continent as one of the large continuous land masses, and Australia is one of them. Its highest point is Kosciuszko. Dick Bass set out to climb the highest point of each of the seven continents as defined that way, and did so.
The case for Carstensz Pyramid
The same encyclopaedias note that New Guinea is a continental island on the Australian shelf, separated from the mainland by the shallow Torres Strait only about 8,000 years ago; a small drop in sea level would join them. If the 7 summits are meant to divide the whole surface of the earth into seven parts and climb the highest point of each, the continental islands belong to their continents, and Carstensz Pyramid, the highest peak between the Himalaya and the Andes, is Oceania's summit. It is also, at 4,884 m16,024 ft with a technical rock climb, a mountain in the sense the other six are.
Why neither answer is clean
If political geography decides, Carstensz Pyramid is in Indonesia and therefore Asia, but then Oceania includes New Zealand and Papua New Guinea, whose highest peaks, Aoraki/Mount Cook at 3,724 m12,218 ft and Mount Wilhelm at 4,509 m14,793 ft, are both far higher than Kosciuszko.
If continental land mass decides, Europe and Asia are one continent and the list has six summits, with Elbrus dropping out.
If continental shelf decides, geologists disagree about where the shelves under Carstensz and under New Zealand begin and end.
What the finisher lists do
The finishers pages keep a Carstensz list, a Kosciuszko list, and a combined list, and mark climbers who have done both. Pat Morrow is credited as the first to complete the Carstensz version, Dick Bass the Kosciuszko version, and neither achievement diminishes the other. Bass invented the idea, paid for the pioneering trips and showed that an amateur with willpower could do it; the argument about the seventh peak came afterwards and is part of the challenge's history rather than a verdict on anyone who completed it.
The guide chapter History and the naming story covers the mountain itself, and Introduction: the 7 summits the two lists.
