Register

Danger, death and turnaround

PlanningBy Harry Kikstra

A life-threatening sport: why the ‘non-technical’ West Buttress is so often under-estimated, and why weather and condition (not a fixed turnaround time) should decide when to descend.

You are engaging in a life-threatening sport: take our disclaimer very seriously. An important safety factor is your choice of team mates, especially if you do not hire a professional guide. If you and your team mates are climbing sensibly, your goal should be that everybody gets back down in good health, whether or not some or all of you reach the summit. There is no summit for which it is worth losing a single finger or toe, let alone risking a life.

The West Buttress route on Denali is often under-estimated because it is a ‘non-technical’ route. But accidents happen every year, some of them lethal, and most of them on the traverse to Denali Pass on summit day, often on the way down. You can minimize the risks by acting responsibly and by listening to guides and rangers. It is foolish to climb without a guide if you lack experience; to climb in a storm; to climb with inadequate gear; to fail to drink or eat enough; or to have irresponsible team mates. You can never eliminate all risk.

Good communication within the team is vital. If you are feeling ill or your fingers are numb, it is a sign of strength, not weakness, to be truthful about it. Anyone can have a bad day, and a fellow team member can raise their morale or lighten their load. Although team members have a duty to help each other, ultimate responsibility for your safety belongs to you, not to your team mates or your guide.

Turnaround time

Some groups believe in having a ‘turnaround time’, an agreed fixed time for turning back from the summit bid in order to descend safely. We disagree: a fixed turnaround time can be a dangerous thing. Weather and your team’s physical and mental condition should be the deciding factors, not your watch. If the weather is turning bad at 08.00, then it is time to turn back, no matter where you are. On the other hand, on a clear and windless summit day, climbers have summited in the late afternoon and still descended safely in daylight.

Sometimes people who should have turned back continue through harsh weather on legs that barely carry them, just because it is not yet ‘turnaround time’. The mountains and the weather are in charge, not you. Always expect to adapt your plans to the conditions. That said, if you are ascending at only 50 metres per hour and reach the top of Denali Pass six hours after leaving High Camp, your progress from there will be much slower still, so draw the obvious conclusion. Assess your chances objectively: if your team is strong in body and mind, the weather is favourable and you are making good time, keep going; but if any of these factors do not feel right, get down in one piece as soon as possible.

Always be honest with yourself and your team mates. If your first attempt is not set to succeed, conserve your energy and you might be able to try again in a few days, when you feel better, are more acclimatized, or the weather has improved. Build flexibility into your schedule, and agree it with your guide and team mates beforehand. In June, thanks to the very long daylight hours, turnaround time is much less of an issue on Denali than elsewhere, and climbers have summited at almost any time of day. It is more important to keep a close eye on the weather: storms can come in very quickly, with devastating results.

← Choosing your routeAltitude effects →
To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.
— Alfred, Lord Tennyson
More quotes →