On 16 February 1623 a Dutch East India Company captain saw snow on the mountains of New Guinea from his ship, and Europe laughed at him. The first part of our history of Carstensz Pyramid follows Jan Carstensz along the coast, explains why nobody went to look for three hundred years, and how his name stuck to the highest mountain in Oceania.
On 16 February 1623 a Dutch ship lay at anchor off the south coast of New Guinea, about a mile and a half from a low, swampy shore. The water was five or six fathoms deep, over a clay bottom. Its commander, Jan Carstensz, looked inland and wrote in his journal that "at a distance of about 10 miles by estimation into the interior, we saw a very high mountain-range in many places white with snow, which we thought a very singular sight, being so near the line equinoctial."
That sentence is the first written record of the highest mountain in Oceania. It took another 339 years for anyone to stand on its summit, and the mountain still carries the name of the man who wrote it: Carstensz Pyramid.
A voyage for the Dutch East India Company
Carstensz was not looking for mountains. He sailed for the Dutch East India Company, the VOC, which in the early seventeenth century was building a trading empire across the islands of what is now Indonesia. The Company wanted to know whether the coasts south of its spice islands held anything worth buying or selling. In 1606 another Company ship, the Duyfken under Willem Janszoon, had sighted land further south. Carstensz was sent to follow it up.
He left Ambon on 21 January 1623 in the yacht Pera, with a second small ship, the Arnhem, and sailed east along the coast of New Guinea. The voyage turned violent almost at once. On 11 February a party went ashore on the New Guinea coast, and the master of the Arnhem and ten of his men were killed in a fight with the people who lived there. Five days later, and a little further along the same coast, came the entry about the snow.
Snow, almost on the equator
What Carstensz saw were the glaciers of the range that now bears his name, a line of limestone peaks at around 4,800 m15,748 ft that carried ice caps at the time. He called it the Sneebergh, the snow mountain. For a seventeenth-century European the idea made no sense. Snow belonged to cold countries and high latitudes; the tropics were hot by definition, and here was a sailor claiming to have seen ice a few degrees from the equator.
He was laughed at for it, and for a long time. The mountains were also hard to see. In 1914 the British explorer Alexander Wollaston, who had spent months in the swamps below the range, told the Alpine Club in London that Carstensz had been "exceedingly fortunate to see the snow mountains from the sea". On very many days, he said, nothing could be seen from the coast "but white banks of fog hanging over the low-lying swamps". He added that there were "ships' captains sailing those seas to-day who still deny the existence of the mountains." Nearly three hundred years after Carstensz, his snow was still a matter of opinion for anyone who had not seen it.
On to Australia
The voyage did not stop for the mountains. The two ships sailed on south and east, and on 12 April 1623 they sighted the coast of Cape York in northern Australia. On 14 April they passed a point the Dutch named Cape Keerweer, and on 8 May, near Cape Duyfken, Carstensz and his crew fought a skirmish with some 200 Aboriginal people. His view of the people he met along these coasts was bleak: he called them "utter barbarians", with no knowledge of precious metals or spices, and that, for the Company, settled the matter. There was nothing to trade.
The ships then separated. The Arnhem crossed the Gulf of Carpentaria and sighted the coast of the region that still carries its name, Arnhem Land. Carstensz took the Pera back to Ambon, which he reached on 8 June 1623. In commercial terms the voyage was a disappointment, and the Company did not send anyone back to look at the snow.
Three centuries of silence
Nothing about the snow mountains changed for almost three hundred years. The coast of southern New Guinea is a belt of mangrove and swamp, cut by wide rivers and backed by some of the densest rain forest on Earth. Behind it the land rises into steep, broken ridges long before the high peaks begin. No outsider had any reason to cross it, and no one could have done so quickly. As Wollaston put it in 1914, from the time of Jan Carstensz until 1909 "no man had ever approached even the foothills of the range."
The people who lived in the highlands, of course, had known the mountains all along. The Amungme, whose land lies on the southern side of the range, call the highest peak Nemangkawi Ninggok, usually translated as "peak of the white arrow". Their name for it is older than any on a European chart, and it is the one carried today by a local trekking company licensed to take climbers up the mountain.
How the name stuck
As Europeans began to map New Guinea in earnest, the range Carstensz had seen was named after him: the Carstensz Toppen on Dutch maps, the Carstensz peaks, with the bare rock summit later called the Carstensz Pyramid. It kept that name through the Dutch colonial period. When Indonesia took over the western half of New Guinea in 1963, the summit was renamed Puncak Sukarno, after the country's first president. Once Sukarno had lost power it became Puncak Jaya, a name that means victory or glory. The story of those years is part 5 of this series.
Climbers never quite let go of the old name, partly because the 7 summits lists were written in English and partly because "Carstensz" is attached to the whole massif and not only to its highest point. Our guide uses both, and Is Puncak Jaya the same as Carstensz Pyramid? sets out the four names side by side.
The snow he saw is nearly gone
The glaciers that made Carstensz's sighting possible have not lasted. When the first expeditions reached the range in the 1930s, the neighbouring summit of Ngga Pulu carried a thick ice cap. It was measured at about 5,030 m16,503 ft and taken to be the highest point of the island. As the ice melted, Ngga Pulu dropped below the rock summit of Carstensz Pyramid, which today stands at 4,884 m16,024 ft. The tropical glaciers have been shrinking for decades, and the last of them are expected to disappear within a few years. Our guide's chapter The mountain and the Sudirman Range describes what is left, and My atlas shows a 5,030 m16,503 ft mountain in Papua that is higher than Carstensz Pyramid. Is it? explains the old height that atlases still print.
In 1623 the snow was the proof that Jan Carstensz had seen something real. Four centuries later a climber flying in from Timika may see almost none of it. The next part of this series follows the first outsiders who tried to walk from the coast to the snow, and the 92 days it took one of them to cover 31 miles.


